Three Quotes, Three Shapes: Comparing Contractor Estimates, and Why We Built Aimitsu
Table of Contents
Anyone who has collected more than one 見積書 (contractor quote) for the same job in Japan knows this moment. You lay three quotes on the table and realise you can’t compare them. One is a single page with five lines. Another runs to three pages with dozens of items. The third has a big round number labelled 諸経費 at the bottom and not much detail above it.
This post is about that moment. The first half covers why it happens and how to handle it yourself with a pen and a spreadsheet. The second half is about Aimitsu, the tool we built because we kept ending up in that moment. I’ll be open about what it does and what it doesn’t.
TL;DR
- Japanese contractor quotes for the same job often can’t be compared directly, because each contractor breaks the work into line items differently.
- 諸経費 (miscellaneous overhead) varies with project size, duration and the costs included, so a percentage alone cannot establish whether it is reasonable. What it includes also varies between contractors. In our experience, requesting its breakdown is a useful starting point for discussion.
- To compare quotes fairly, first align the scope, quantities and specifications, then compare category totals. If an item is not separately listed, confirm whether it is included elsewhere, excluded or unnecessary.
- The lowest quoted total is not necessarily the lowest cost for the same scope.
- Aimitsu extracts the line items from an uploaded 見積書 and assesses the prices against regional market rates. You still decide.
Why Don’t Quotes for the Same Job Line Up?
Quotes for the same job don’t line up because each contractor decides for themselves how finely to split the work. One contractor’s single “bathroom renovation” line can be another’s fifteen lines of demolition, plumbing, tiling and fixtures. Neither is wrong. They’re just different shapes of the same work.
That means comparing totals tells you very little. A quote can look cheap because it leaves something out, not because the work costs less. If an item is not separately listed, confirm whether it is included elsewhere, excluded or unnecessary. Required work outside the agreed scope may involve additional charges, so clarify the scope and price before you authorize it.
We run short-term rental properties, so we get quotes all the time: wallpaper, plumbing, small renovations, repairs after a guest has left. Comparing them by hand took a long time, and we weren’t always sure we’d got it right.
How Can You Compare Quotes Fairly by Hand?
To compare quotes fairly, first make sure every quote covers the same work, and only then compare the money. Here’s the method we used before we built a tool. It works with nothing more than a spreadsheet:
- Choose your categories. For a bathroom job that might be demolition, plumbing, waterproofing and tiling, fixtures, electrical, disposal, and overhead. Keep the list short. Use broad categories, but verify their contents.
- Align scope, quantities, units and specifications. For each line in each quote, check what it covers: the area in m², the number of fixtures, the units used and the material grade. Where a contractor bundles mixed work into one line, mark it “breakdown pending” and keep it out of the category comparison. Either ask the contractor to break it down, or add up the matching lines from the other quotes into an equivalent bundle.
- Add up the totals by category once the contents match. The differences start showing here. If one quote’s plumbing is far higher or lower than the others, find out why. Matching category labels alone don’t prove that two quotes cover the same work.
- Write down what isn’t listed. For each quote, note which items aren’t listed separately. For each one, confirm whether it is included elsewhere, excluded or unnecessary. Required work outside the agreed scope may involve additional charges, so clarify the scope and price before you authorize it.
- Work out 諸経費 as a percentage. Use the same convention for every quote: overhead percentage = separately stated overhead ÷ total of the other pre-tax quoted charges × 100. For example, ¥100,000 ÷ ¥1,000,000 × 100 = 10%. Contractors may use a different calculation base, and some overhead may be bundled into other items, so take that into account too.
It’s slow, but it changes how you talk to contractors. “Why is your plumbing line so different?” gets a much better answer than “Can you go lower?”
How Should You Read the 諸経費 Line?
Treat 諸経費 as the first thing to ask about, not as a fixed fee. It covers a contractor’s general costs, such as site management, transport and admin. Overhead varies with project size, duration and the costs included, so a percentage alone cannot establish whether it is reasonable. What overhead includes also varies between contractors.
A high percentage doesn’t mean anyone is being dishonest. A contractor may put costs in 諸経費 that another lists separately. That’s exactly why you need the percentage next to the category breakdown: you can see whether a high 諸経費 is making up for a cheaper line item elsewhere, or simply adding to the total. In our experience, requesting its breakdown is a useful starting point for discussion.
What Did We Build, and How Does It Work?
We built Aimitsu, an AI tool that checks contractor quotes. You upload a renovation or maintenance 見積書, and Aimitsu extracts the line items and assesses the prices against regional market rates. That shows you which lines look high or low for your area.
It works differently from the spreadsheet method. Instead of only comparing your quotes with each other, it compares each line with market rates for your region. Those are the core features, and I’d rather describe them accurately than make them sound bigger. It doesn’t negotiate for you. It doesn’t judge the quality of the work. It doesn’t tell you which contractor to pick. What it gives you is a starting point for questions, without spending an evening typing in quotes.
Where Does Aimitsu Fit, and Where Doesn’t It?
Aimitsu is most useful when you have a quote and aren’t sure whether its prices are reasonable, even if it’s the only quote you have. It’s a good fit for property owners, small hospitality operators and anyone who doesn’t price construction work every day.
It’s less useful in other cases:
- You need an exact like-for-like comparison of several quotes. A market-rate assessment doesn’t replace the work of aligning scope, quantities and specifications across quotes yourself, as described above.
- The real question is about quality. A price that looks high against market rates is a prompt to ask a question, not a verdict. A more expensive line may mean better materials or a more experienced trade.
- Your relationship with a contractor matters more than the price. If you’ve worked with a contractor for years and trust them, a few percent may not change your decision. That’s a perfectly reasonable choice.
Either way, you should still read the quotes yourself. Check what isn’t listed, ask about bundled lines, and get clear answers before you sign.
FAQ
Q: What is a normal 諸経費 percentage on a Japanese contractor quote?
Overhead varies with project size, duration and the costs included, so a percentage alone cannot establish whether it is reasonable. Calculate it the same way for each quote (separately stated overhead ÷ total of the other pre-tax quoted charges × 100) and compare the results alongside the category breakdown. A high figure is a reason to ask what it covers, not proof that the quote is overpriced.
Q: Is the quote with the lowest total the best deal?
Not necessarily. A lower total may exclude necessary work. If an item is not separately listed, confirm whether it is included elsewhere, excluded or unnecessary. Required work outside the agreed scope may involve additional charges. Compare the same scope category by category before deciding.
Q: Does Aimitsu choose a contractor for me?
No. Aimitsu extracts the line items from your 見積書 and assesses the prices against regional market rates. Deciding what to ask, what to negotiate and who to hire is still up to you.
Comments