The first time someone asked me whether BenStay was a 株式会社 or a 合同会社, I panicked a little. I’d spent weeks researching and was fairly confident in my decision, but being asked out loud made me second-guess everything.

That was a few years ago. Since then I’ve talked to enough other small hospitality operators and foreign founders to know that this decision causes far more stress than it should. So here’s the clear-headed breakdown I wish I’d had.

TL;DR

  • For many small hospitality operators in Japan, a 合同会社 (GK / LLC) is a sensible default. Its statutory setup cost is lower: from ¥60,000 for a GK, against about ¥165,000 for a KK, assuming electronic articles and before professional fees. It also has less ongoing admin.
  • GK and KK generally face the same Japanese corporate-income-tax rules under equivalent circumstances. You have to check eligibility for particular incentives separately, and some investor-side reliefs (such as angel tax relief) apply only to qualifying KKs.
  • A KK can issue shares, which is what conventional venture investors expect. A GK can’t issue shares, but it can admit investors as new members. If you plan to raise venture-style investment, a KK is generally the better fit.
  • In my experience at BenStay, being a GK has not stopped us working with our hospitality partners.
  • You can convert a GK into a KK later, but it takes a formal procedure, including a creditor-objection period of at least one month. Think through the investment question upfront.

Two structures, one real choice

Japan has several types of legal entity, but for a small hospitality business you’re really choosing between two:

  • 株式会社 (KabushikiKaisha / KK): the traditional joint-stock company. It’s what most people picture when they think “Japanese company.”
  • 合同会社 (GōdōKaisha / GK): the LLC equivalent, introduced by the Companies Act that took effect on May 1, 2006 (法務省—会社法の施行に伴う会社登記についてのQ&A). It’s simpler and cheaper, and it’s increasingly common.

Both are 法人 (legal persons), and both separate your personal liability from the business. Under equivalent circumstances, both generally follow the same corporate-income-tax rules. The differences are in cost, governance, how they take on investors, and perception.

Setup costs: a real difference

A KK must have its articles of incorporation (定款) certified by a notary public. The notary fee depends on capital:

  • ¥30,000 for capital under ¥1 million
  • ¥40,000 for ¥1 million to under ¥3 million
  • ¥50,000 above that

Since December 1, 2024, a KK with capital under ¥1 million pays only ¥15,000 if it meets all three of these conditions: it has no more than three founders, all of them individuals; those founders subscribe all the shares issued at formation; and it has no board of directors (定款認証—銀座公証役場).

For both types, registration tax (登録免許税) is 0.7% of capital, with a minimum of ¥150,000 for a KK and ¥60,000 for a GK (No.7191 登録免許税の税額表—国税庁). A GK’s articles don’t need notarization at all (合同会社の設立手続き—J-Net21).

Assume electronic articles, capital small enough that the minimum registration tax applies, and no professional fees. On that basis, statutory costs start at about ¥165,000 for a KK that qualifies for the reduced notary fee, ¥180,000–200,000 for one that doesn’t, and ¥60,000 for a GK. Paper articles add ¥40,000 of stamp duty for either structure. Certified copies, company seals, and fees for a judicial scrivener or an incorporation service all come on top.

When you’re bootstrapping, that gap is real money. I put ours toward the first month’s operating expenses.

Ongoing administration

A KK must publish an annual financial announcement (決算公告). Depending on the method set in its articles, that goes in the official gazette (官報), a daily newspaper, or an electronic public notice. A KK that uses the gazette or a newspaper can instead make its financial statements continuously available on a website for five years (Companies Act, Articles 440 and 939). Whichever method you choose, it’s a recurring task. A GK has no annual 決算公告 obligation.

A KK also comes with more governance formalities, though less than people often assume. A small KK whose shares all carry transfer restrictions can generally have a single director and no board (JETRO—1.2 拠点形態の比較), so a solo founder doesn’t need board-meeting minutes. You still have to keep a shareholder register, record shareholder resolutions, and reappoint directors and register the reappointment when their terms end. A GK’s governance is simpler still, which suits a solo founder running a handful of properties.

The tax myth

This one comes up constantly: “KK has better tax treatment.”

As a general rule, it doesn’t. Under equivalent circumstances, GK and KK face the same Japanese corporate-income-tax rules and rates (No.5759 法人税の税率—国税庁). You have to check eligibility for any particular incentive separately.

Both can pay officer remuneration (役員報酬) to directors or representative members and deduct it from corporate income, but only within the officer-remuneration rules. In practice that usually means fixed regular pay (定期同額給与) or predetermined pay that has been properly notified in advance (事前確定届出給与), and any amount judged excessive is not deductible (No.5211 役員に対する給与—国税庁).

One real difference sits with your investors rather than the company. Under the angel tax scheme (エンジェル税制), individuals who make eligible investments in qualifying KKs can get tax relief, and that relief doesn’t cover GK membership interests (No.1544 エンジェル税制の概要等—国税庁).

The bigger tax milestone to map early is Japan’s ¥10 million consumption tax threshold. Broadly, a company loses the exemption for a business year if its taxable sales in the base period (基準期間) exceeded ¥10 million. For a company with annual accounting periods, the base period is normally the business year two years earlier, and sales of exactly ¥10 million don’t exceed the threshold. There are exceptions:

  • the specified-period (特定期間) test, based broadly on the first six months of the previous business year
  • rules for new companies with capital of ¥10 million or more, or controlled by a large business
  • qualified-invoice registration, which makes you a taxable business regardless of your sales

Becoming taxable because your sales crossed the threshold is handled by filing the taxable-business notification (消費税課税事業者届出書). Qualified-invoice registration (適格請求書発行事業者の登録) is a separate application (No.6501 納税義務の免除—国税庁). These rules apply to a GK and a KK in the same way.

What about credibility?

Here’s the honest answer: 株式会社 does carry more traditional prestige in Japan. It’s what most people picture as a “real” company, and some older or more conservative Japanese businesses may raise an eyebrow at 合同会社.

In my experience at BenStay, being a GK has not prevented us from working with our hospitality partners: OTAs, property management companies, and cleaning and maintenance contractors. I can’t speak for every counterparty, though. If a particular partner matters to your business, ask them.

It might matter in a few cases: applying for certain traditional bank loans, or building B2B relationships with large, conservative Japanese corporations. If that’s your business model, a KK may be worth the extra cost for perception alone.

For us, it hasn’t been a factor.

The investment question

This is where the choice matters most structurally. A KK can issue shares (株式), the instrument conventional venture investors expect. A GK can’t issue shares, but it isn’t closed to investors. It can admit a new investing member through a contribution and an amendment to its articles of incorporation (Companies Act, Article 604). GK members hold 持分 (membership interests), not shares.

If you might raise money from a Japanese VC or angel investors, a KK is generally the more suitable vehicle: share issuance is what those investors are set up for, and angel tax relief applies only to qualifying KKs.

If you’re planning to stay bootstrapped and private, none of this affects you.

You can convert a GK into a KK later, but it takes a formal procedure and some cost. If there’s a real chance you’ll want venture-style investment, starting as a KK might save you a headache down the line.

If you’re thinking about an eventual exit, read what actually transfers in a Japan short-term rental business sale before you finalise the structure. Company type affects how that conversation unfolds.

Why BenStay is a 合同会社

When I set up BenStay, the calculus was straightforward:

  1. Lower setup cost: meaningful when bootstrapping
  2. Less ongoing admin: no annual 決算公告 and simpler governance
  3. Same corporate-tax rules: no corporate-tax downside for a company like ours
  4. Our business context: in our experience, being a GK hasn’t got in the way with our hospitality partners
  5. No current plans to raise equity: the GK structure fits our model

One thing I’d flag for other founders: if you’re not sure whether you’ll raise investment in the next few years, think carefully before defaulting to GK. Under the assumptions above, starting as a KK and never needing it costs at least about ¥105,000 more in statutory fees, plus the extra admin. Starting as a GK and later needing to convert costs time, professional fees, and administrative work.

The bottom line

If you’re a solo founder or small team setting up a hospitality business in Japan:

  • A GK is a sensible default if you plan to stay owner-run, don’t expect to bring in share investors, and don’t need a KK’s governance structure.
  • It saves setup cost and ongoing admin.
  • Don’t assume anything about prestige. Check with the counterparties that matter to you, such as a lender or a large corporate partner.
  • Choose a KK if you might raise venture-style equity investment, or if your business depends on credibility with very traditional Japanese corporate partners.

The company structure is a foundation, not a competitive advantage. Get it set up, and get on with building the actual business.

Once the entity is registered, a practical next step is opening a Japanese bank account for a short-term rental business. It’s a process of its own, and foreign operators run into friction that’s worth knowing about in advance.

FAQ

Q: Can I convert from GK to KK later if I need to raise investment?

Yes, Japanese law allows a GK to convert (組織変更) into a KK. The steps are a conversion plan approved by all members, a creditor-protection procedure with a creditor-objection period of at least one month, and then registration, so allow for preparation and registration time on top of that month (Companies Act, Articles 779 and 781). Most people hire a judicial scrivener (司法書士). Costs vary by case, so get an itemized quote that separates taxes, publication costs, and professional fees. If there’s a real chance you’ll raise venture-style equity, starting as a KK avoids the process.

Q: Do banks treat GK and KK differently for business loans?

Both structures can apply for corporate banking, subject to each institution’s eligibility, documentation, and screening requirements. Some banks state outright that they accept both: GMO Aozora’s corporate-account FAQ is one example (GMO Aozora corporate-account FAQ). Others ask for different documents depending on company type. Resona lists different ownership-verification documents for different types of company (Resona—法人口座開設で必要な書類). For loans, check each lender’s own criteria.

Q: Is BenStay still a GK? Any regrets?

Still a GK, no regrets. Our business model doesn’t require outside equity, and the lower setup cost and lighter admin were meaningful while we were bootstrapping. The only way I’d have chosen differently is if we’d planned to take VC money from the start.

Sources


This post is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal or tax advice. Company registration requirements and tax laws change — please consult a qualified Japanese lawyer, judicial scrivener (司法書士), or tax advisor (税理士) for your specific situation.